Making a Pay-Per-Click Ad Campaign Work for Affinity Insurance


If you are a director of an insurance trust or an affinity insurance group and you want to expand your digital footprint, we understand you. Your goal is to target prospective members of your parent organization in an effective way, through pay-per-click advertising (PPC) and other digital advertising, but you face unique challenges that other traditional insurance agencies do not need to overcome.  To face up to the challenge and succeed, your mission is twofold: (1) you must acknowledge the advantage that you likely already have: increased data and insights about your prospects, and (2) leverage your advantage by implementing creative strategies that target your audience with powerful, customized messaging.

With that in mind, here are a few paid advertising tactics to consider.

Search and Display-Based Ads for Affinity Insurance Groups

Perhaps your affinity insurance group is hesitant to explore the PPC advertising option. After all, your audience is very limited; why pay for broadcasting a message to those who aren’t eligible to purchase your insurance product? But you can succeed with search-based and display-based ads. You can reach your specific audience, and limit the number of clicks from uneligible leads. To run a successful search-based campaign, consider these three tactics in order to help improve your effectiveness.

target audience affinity insuranceBe selective with targeting. Keywords are powerful, but you must use them correctly to get the results you want. Use only keywords that are phrase-matched and broad-modified so that you reduce the likelihood of off-topic keywords triggering your ad display.

For example, suppose you are trying to target teachers in your state association to see an ad for life insurance. To be effective, exact modify words like “educator” or “teacher” in your keywords, combined with the product offered. (“educator life insurance”, or “teacher life insurance”)

Also, consider targeting your parent organization’s branded keywords to raise awareness of offers that are available to members. As your campaign progresses, review analytics, and utilize negative keywords and actual search term data to continue to refine your keyword list.

Write clear ad copy. Where appropriate in your search based ads, make sure to include your connection to your parent organization as prominently as possible. This will immediately create in your prospect a sense of familiarity with your brand, establish a sense of trust, and show that you can specialize services to fit their interests. This is also a highly effective way to help limit clicks from ineligible customers.

Utilize Audience and Demographic Data. Until recently, the most powerful tool that Google Ads had for association marketing was their customer match feature. Association or affinity insurance groups had the ability to upload member lists from their CRM and target directly to those identified emails. Unfortunately, Google recently made a policy change where these features are only available to accounts with (1) a lifetime spend of over $50,000, (2) an account at least 90 days old and (3) a personal account manager at Google. At this time, these features are now inaccessible for many advertisers.

But all is not lost. Insurance groups can still use retargeting ads. By sharing analytic data from their parent organization, insurance trusts can effectively educate members and reinforce product-specific messaging to those who already have an awareness of your insurance products. It is also valuable for association insurance groups to be selective with demographics. For instance, a professional association will likely have success in removing the 18-24 year old demographic, and possibly those over age 65.

marketing for affinity insurance

Video Ads for Affinity Insurance Groups

If you were to guess, what would you say is the second most-used search engine in the United States? Bing? DuckDuckGo? Many are surprised at the answer: it’s actually YouTube.*

affinity insurance marketing

Since YouTube is owned by Google, you can target YouTube channels and keywords with Google display ads. Beyond display ads, video ads on YouTube can be an effective tool in reaching your audience.

One of the biggest challenges that association insurance agencies experience is the lack of personal connection that their target audience feels toward them. By using video ads on YouTube, affinity insurance groups can utilize retargeting lists, segment them by product pages, then speak directly to their prospects. You can reinforce your position as an organization that is uniquely qualified to meet their needs, or take the opportunity to continue educating them about the particular insurance product they should see. 

Successful Marketing for Affinity Insurance

If you want to run a PPC campaign that works for your affinity insurance group, Seapoint Digital can help you. We have experience in creating and implementing powerful digital marketing campaigns that get stunning results.

The next article in this series will explore social media advertising for affinity insurance groups.

Reach out for help with your strategy by completing the form below.